Skip to Content

10 Common Mistakes to Avoid in Your Herb Garden Full Guide of 2023

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

herb garden mistakes to avoidYou’re keen to start an herb garden but want to sidestep the common pitfalls. Growing herbs may seem simple, but even seasoned gardeners make mistakes. By learning what to avoid upfront, you’ll be on the path to herb garden success.

The ideal spot to grow herbs isn’t always obvious. You’ll want to carefully consider sunlight, drainage, and proximity to other plants. Don’t underestimate how much space herbs need either. Overcrowding is one of the biggest herb garden mistakes, stunting growth.

You’ll need to care for your herbs too, with regular pruning, watering, and feeding. Herbs thrive on neglect is a myth! And resist the urge to let flowers bloom, as this diverts energy from leaf production.

Follow these tips to create a flourishing herb garden, and you’ll reap homegrown flavor all season long.

Key Takeaways

  • Improper placement and spacing can hinder healthy growth, and overcrowding should be avoided.
  • Regular pruning and prevention of flowering can stimulate new leaf growth and maintain flavor.
  • Proper soil drainage, watering routines, mulching, and nutrition are essential for herb garden care.
  • Managing specific herbs, such as planting mint in containers and considering sunlight and soil preferences, is crucial for successful cultivation.

Growing Your Herbs in the Wrong Place

Growing Your Herbs in the Wrong Place
You’ll want to double-check your herbs’ light and moisture needs before planting, so they don’t end up struggling in the wrong spot. Garden centers label herbs with sun versus shade icons, but you have to ensure you’re planting in the perfect spot.

Mediterranean herbs like rosemary and lavender need full sunlight to thrive; planting them in too much shade leads to poor growth and discourages use. Likewise, overly moist soil causes basil and mint to deteriorate quickly. Monitor sunlight patterns in your garden and pick high-drainage areas for Mediterranean herbs.

For shade-tolerant herbs, ensure the site gets a little sun but avoids intense afternoon rays. With careful placement, your herbs will flourish and provide maximum harvests instead of becoming stunted, lifeless plants.

Creating a Herb Crowd

Creating a Herb Crowd
Don’t jam too many herbs in too small a space – they need room to breathe and grow.

  1. Provide at least 12 inches between plants.
  2. Check spacing recommendations for each herb variety.
  3. Consider eventual size and spread when planting.
  4. Adjust spacing seasonally as herbs grow.

When initially planting your herb garden, it’s tempting to crowd as many varieties together as possible. However, this often stunts the growth and compromises the health of the plants. Be sure to research the recommended spacing for each herb and allow ample room between plants.

This will ensure they receive sufficient sunlight, airflow, and space for their root systems.

Adjust spacing as needed through the seasons to accommodate growth. With the proper room to thrive, your herbs will reward you with robust flavor and growth year after year.

Forgetting to Cut Your Herbs Regularly

Forgetting to Cut Your Herbs Regularly
Neglecting regular cutting shortchanges your herbs’ health and hampers your harvest. Pruning your herbs to use encourages side shoots and new leaf growth, maximizing foliage health and production. Trim off flowering buds to direct the plant’s energy into leaf growth instead of setting seed.

Harvest new stem tips and tender top leaves but leave some foliage so your herb can keep growing. Proper maintenance with frequent cutting gives you a continuous supply of flavorful herbs for months from each established plant.

With a little care, your potted herbs can thrive indoors through winter for year-round fresh herbs on hand.

Trust your eyes and frequent tending to each plant’s needs. Master herb cutting and you’ll be rewarded with healthy, robust herbs and harvests.

Letting Herb Flowers Go to Seed

Letting Herb Flowers Go to Seed
Since letting herbs flower reduces lifespan, snip off blooms early. Frequent deadheading prevents herbs like basil, thyme, and oregano from going to seed. This simple gardening task extends your herb’s productive lifespan and maintains the plant’s focus on leaf and stem growth.

Harvest the tender new growths regularly before flowers appear. Monitor maturing herbs daily and collect opening buds right away.

Prepare soil with proper drainage and nutrients to discourage early bolting. Give herbs sufficient sunlight and space to grow. Don’t neglect pruning and harvesting. Snip off blooms as soon as you spot them to keep herbs happy and prevent a drop in oil production and flavor.

Not Adding Gravel to Your Soil

Not Adding Gravel to Your Soil
Letting flowers go to seed drains energy from herb plants. Now let’s talk about not adding gravel to your soil. This is a crucial misstep for a thriving herb garden. Without gravel, the soil becomes dense and soggy.

Herbs need air pockets for the roots to breathe. Gravel improves drainage, allowing oxygen and moisture to penetrate the soil.

  • Mix in 1 part gravel per 2 parts soil.
  • Create gravel drainage layers in pots.
  • Top dress gardens annually with fresh gravel.

Proper soil preparation gives your herbs the ideal foundation to grow. Well-draining soil keeps roots oxygenated while retaining just enough moisture.

Believing Your Herbs Don’t Need Water

Believing Your Herbs Don
You’re risking shriveled, unhealthy herbs if you don’t water them properly. Understanding your herbs’ moisture needs is crucial to their vitality.

Overwatering can be as detrimental as underwatering – both lead to problems. Keep a watchful eye on the drying soil and learn to gauge moisture levels by touch.

Each herb has its own watering frequency; basil prefers slightly more moisture than thyme, for instance. Remember that most herbs thrive in well-draining soil, so ensure proper drainage to prevent waterlogged roots.

When caring for herbs, consistency is key. Adjust your watering routine based on weather conditions and the specific requirements of your chosen herbs.

By mastering the art of watering, you’re well on your way to nurturing a flourishing herb garden.

Not Mulching Your Herb Garden

Not Mulching Your Herb Garden
Coverin’ them roots retains moisture and keeps your herbs happy. Mulching ain’t just about good looks—it’s an herb garden essential.

  1. Conserve Moisture: Mulch acts like a cozy blanket, keepin’ soil moist without drownin’ your herbs.

  2. Blocking Weeds: It’s like a shield against those pesky invaders, lettin’ your herbs shine without competition.

  3. Retaining Nutrients: Mulch slowly breaks down, feedin’ your herbs over time—no need for constant fertilizer fussin’.

  4. Preventing Erosion: Rain can wash away your soil, but mulch stands strong, protectin’ your herbs’ foundation.

So, spread that mulch about 2-3 inches thick ’round your herbs, but give ’em some breathing room ’round the stems. It’s like givin’ your garden a warm hug that promotes growth, keeps it neat, and stops those herb flowers from stealin’ the show.

Not Feeding Your Herbs

Not Feeding Your Herbs
Keep those herbs well-fed, ’cause skimpin’ on nutrients’ll stunt their growth. Herbs need a balanced diet just like we do. Without proper nutrition, their leaves can turn yellow or growth can slow way down.

Feed ’em weekly with organic fertilizers or nutrient-rich compost to enrich the soil. Make sure they get all the nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium they need. Give herbs in containers liquid plant foods since their roots have less access to nutrients.

And don’t forget – good drainage and aeration helps them absorb supplements fully.

Feeding Method Effect
Organic granular fertilizer Slow-release nutrition
Compost and manure Improves soil health
Fish emulsion Quick nitrogen boost
Worm castings Rich in micronutrients

Regularly feeding your herbs creates happy, productive plants. Follow their cues, and you’ll be rewarded with robust flavor and growth for months to come.

Planting Mint in Your Garden

Planting Mint in Your Garden
Puttin’ that mint straight in the ground will make your garden go wild! Mint’s aggressive roots will take over your beds, so keep it contained.

Plant mint in pots, raised beds, or garden edges for easier control. Use gritty, fast-draining soil and trim regularly to prevent flowering and contain growth.

Snip off 3-4 cuttings in spring or fall to propagate new plants. Mint thrives with sun but tolerates some shade too.

Respect mint’s spreading nature by giving it space or isolation. With good drainage and frequent cutting back, you’ll get the intense minty flavor you love without sacrificing your garden!

Buying Diseased Herbs in the First Place

Buying Diseased Herbs in the First Place
When diving into the world of cultivating your own aromatic treasures, it’s crucial to steer clear of a misstep that can swiftly sabotage your gardening dreams: starting off with a batch of ailing plants right from the get-go.

Inspecting quality becomes your first line of defense. Recognizing symptoms of disease or pest infestations, even in the subtlest forms, is your secret weapon. Prevention measures begin with healthy plant selection – opt for vigorous, bug-free herbs.

Make sure to thoroughly examine both sides of leaves and the undersides for hidden culprits.

Moreover, germination rates are key; understanding them can save you frustration. If you’re delving into the realm of high-maintenance herbs or trying your hand at indoor gardening, proper herb compatibility is a compass to successful pairings.

Your journey to mastery involves starting strong, avoiding pitfalls, and setting the stage for thriving herb growth.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I plant different herbs together in the same container even if they have different sunlight requirements?

Planting diverse herbs in one container, like conducting a symphony of flavors, demands finesse. Pair sun-soakers with sun-seekers, considering their thirst. Skillful artistry allows various herbs to harmonize, creating a culinary masterpiece.

Is it possible to salvage herbs that have started flowering, or should I replace them with new plants?

To salvage flowering herbs, trim off flowers promptly. Focus on new growth and keep pruning regularly. This redirects energy into foliage, maintaining better flavor. Remember, continuous care leads to mastery in herb gardening.

How do I know if my soil needs gravel for better drainage, and how much should I add?

To determine if your soil needs gravel for better drainage, perform a simple test. Dig a hole and fill it with water. If it drains slowly, add gravel in a 1:4 ratio with soil.

Are there any natural alternatives to compost tea for feeding my herbs?

Boost herb growth naturally. Replace compost tea with homemade alternatives. Try diluted fish emulsion or seaweed extract for nutrient-rich feeding.

What signs should I look for to identify pests or diseases on my newly purchased herb plants?

Inspect newly purchased herb plants for signs of pests or diseases. Examine both sides of leaves and underneath leaves for insects, eggs, or discoloration.


Congratulations, fellow herb enthusiast, you’re about to embark on a gardening journey that’s both delightful and rewarding. But, hold your trowel, for the path to herb-growing nirvana is not without its twists and turns.

As you step into the realm of herb cultivation, brace yourself for the 10 mistakes that could easily thwart your green dreams.

  1. Misplaced Marvels: It’s as if you’re casting your herbs into a botanical Bermuda Triangle. Remember, herbs have preferences too. Ignoring their sun, shade, and moisture needs is like asking a fish to dance on land.

  2. The Herb Jam: Your herbs are elbowing each other like eager concertgoers. Give them room to spread their metaphorical wings or they’ll cramp each other’s style.

  3. Trim, Trim, Trim: Your herbs are party animals, always growing, and sometimes unruly. If you’re not wielding your pruning shears like a seasoned barber, you’re depriving them of the chic haircut they deserve.

  4. No Seed of Doubt: Herb flowers, delightful as they are, can be deceptive. Allow them to seed and you’ll have a botanical takeover. Snip those flowers, or your herbs will conquer the garden like a determined general.

  5. Gravel Magic: Like an artist preparing a canvas, mix gravel into your soil for impeccable drainage. This magical touch prevents herb roots from feeling like they’re stuck in a swamp.

  6. Thirsty Truths: Herbs, like you, need their hydration. Neglect their water supply and you’re sentencing them to a drought disaster. But remember, direct water to the roots, not a leafy sprinkle.

  7. Mulch Marvels: Think of mulch as a cozy blanket for your herbs. It keeps them warm, prevents water evaporation, and deters weeds. Just don’t smother their stems like you’re piling on marshmallows.

  8. Feed the Green Giants: Those herbs are like athletes – they need fuel to shine. Skip feeding them and you’re staging a hunger strike. Compost tea is their gourmet dish; serve it regularly and watch them flourish.

  9. Mint Mayhem: Plant mint in your garden and it’ll act like the party guest who overstays their welcome. It’s like inviting a rock star to a quiet tea party. Keep mint in a container, lest your garden becomes its eternal stage.

  10. Disease Detectives: Buying diseased herbs is like welcoming a Trojan horse into your sanctuary. Thoroughly inspect those leaves for bugs and their tiny minions before letting them breach your garden walls.

So, my green-thumbed friend, as you set foot on this herby adventure, remember these 10 missteps to avoid. Your herb garden is not just a bunch of plants; it’s a symphony of fragrances, flavors, and beauty.

By steering clear of these pitfalls, you’re ensuring that your garden becomes a harmonious haven for the senses—a place where mistakes are eclipsed by the joy of nurturing vibrant, thriving herbs.

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is a published author and software engineer and agriculture expert from the US. To date, he has helped thousands of people make their yards lush and thick.