Skip to Content

Comparing Vigoro & Scotts: Which Fertilizer is Better for Your Lawn? (2023)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

Are you looking for a fertilizer to keep your lawn in top condition? You may have heard of two popular brands: Vigoro and Scotts.

In this article, we’ll compare the two fertilizers head-to-head and take an in-depth look at their cost, ease of application, customer service ratings, and more. We’ll also share our personal experience with both products so that you can make an informed decision on what is best for your lawn care needs.

So, if you want the best bang for your buck while keeping weeds away, read on!

Key Takeaways

is vigoro fertilizer as good as scotts
While Vigoro is 31.5% cheaper on average than Scotts, Scotts is better at producing lush and natural-looking grass, while Vigoro is better at weed prevention. Both brands offer granular and liquid products, but choosing the right fertilizer involves considering factors such as shade, sunlight, foot traffic, and climate.

Organic fertilizers require more frequent applications but provide long-lasting benefits without harming beneficial insects.

Comparing Vigoro and Scotts: Which is Better?

Comparing Vigoro and Scotts: Which is Better?
When it comes to lawn care, you may be wondering which brand is better – Scotts or Vigoro.

Both brands offer organic fertilizers that are safe for pets and conserve water. However, their environmental impact differs in terms of grass types they’re suitable for. Scotts produces more lush and natural-looking grass while Vigoro is better at weed prevention.

In terms of customer support options, Scotts has an edge over Vigoro with a money-back guarantee if not satisfied with performance results.

Furthermore, both brands have granular as well as liquid products. But when picking the right fertilizer, there are other factors like shade, sunlight, foot traffic, etc.

The purpose of this article was to help determine whether either product would suit your particular situation.

Cost Comparison: Vigoro is 31.5% Cheaper Than Scotts

Cost Comparison: Vigoro is 31.5% Cheaper Than Scotts
When it comes to cost, Vigoro is the clear winner. On average, you can expect to pay 31.5% less for a Vigoro fertilizer than a similar Scotts product. This makes it an excellent choice if you are looking for more bang for your buck or have limited funds available to buy lawn care products on a regular basis.

However, there are other factors that need consideration before making your decision. Watering and soil quality requirements, as well as pet safety and climate effects, should be taken into account when deciding between these two brands.

It’s essential to ensure that the fertilizer is applied correctly, and the amount applied is appropriate for the climate.

When examining both brands side-by-side, Vigoro Weed & Feed kills weeds down to their roots while also providing nourishment that lasts up to two months. Sunday Lawn Care offers another alternative with its 7-day guarantee against pests and weeds, but it does not provide long-lasting protection like its competitors do when regularly applied according to the directions provided by each individual manufacturer.

Additionally, Scotts has a money-back guarantee if customers aren’t satisfied with their purchase. This gives consumers extra peace of mind, knowing they get what they paid for without risking additional costs upfront due to defective or subpar performance from either brand’s Lawn Fertilizer or Lawn Care Products, respectively.

In summary, Vigoro is a cost-effective option for those looking to save money on lawn care products. However, it’s essential to consider other factors such as watering and soil quality requirements, pet safety, and climate effects before making a decision.

Ease of Application: How to Apply Lawn Fertilizer

Ease of Application: How to Apply Lawn Fertilizer
You can easily apply lawn fertilizer with either Scotts or Vigoro, giving your grass the nourishment it needs for a lush and healthy look.

Both offer granular and liquid products that require different methods of application. Granular fertilizers are sprinkled over the lawn using a spreader while liquid fertilizers are sprayed evenly using a garden hose or sprayer attachment.

Organic fertilizers may require more frequent applications but provide long-lasting benefits to soil nutrients and turf care without harming beneficial insects in your yard.

For weed control, both Scotts Lawn Fertilizer and Vigoro Weed & Feed contain herbicides that kill weeds down to the roots while also promoting thick green growth on your lawn in shorter time frames than organic alternatives.

However, be sure to follow instructions carefully when applying any type of fertilizer as improper use can lead to damage or loss of grass.

Different people have different preferences when it comes to applying lawn treatments so choose what works best for you based on factors such as shade/sunlight exposure, foot traffic/pet use patterns around your home’s exterior space(s), environmental considerations (e.

Customer Service: Vigoro Vs. Scotts

Customer Service: Vigoro Vs. Scotts
Comparing customer service, Scotts has a clear edge over its competitor, offering more options and support for their products. Consumers can take advantage of the money-back guarantee on some Scotts brand products, as well as get assistance with phone calls or online chats.

On the other hand, Vigoro also offers help, but it is limited to email inquiries only. When it comes to organic fertilizer options, Vigoro Super Green stands out from the competition thanks to its ability to work in all shade exposure levels and its pet-safe formula.

Additionally, consumers should consider environmental impacts when choosing between brands since both offer granular and liquid fertilizers that can have an effect on surrounding ecosystems if applied incorrectly or too frequently throughout the year (2-4 times/year).

The choice between these two lawn care companies really depends on what factors are most important: cost savings vs customer service; safety vs performance; convenience vs longevity of effects, etc.

Our Experience With Scotts and Vigoro

Our Experience With Scotts and Vigoro
Seeing the results of using both Scotts and Vigoro products firsthand can be awe-inspiring, giving your lawn a lush green look in no time. Our experience with these two brands has been positive overall, but each has its strengths and weaknesses.

In terms of weed prevention, we found that Vigoro Weed and Feed was more effective than Scotts Turf Builder Weed Control due to its assurance particle technology. However, when it comes to sunlight factors such as shade or foot traffic on the lawn or pet use, Scotts may be a better option as they offer various formulas for different needs.

Both brands have time-released nitrogen options for extended feeding periods which is great for lawns that need constant nourishment throughout the season. Additionally, if you’re looking for an organic option, then there are alternatives available too like Sunday Lawn Care’s best organic lawn fertilizer which provides nutrients without any harmful chemicals.

When purchasing fertilizers from Home Depot, customers should keep in mind their money-back guarantee policy before making any decisions.

Alternatives to Scotts and Vigoro Weed and Feed

Alternatives to Scotts and Vigoro Weed and Feed
When it comes to weed prevention, fertilizer selection isn’t just about choosing between Scotts and Vigoro. There are plenty of alternatives out there that can offer great results without breaking the bank.

One popular option is Sunday Lawn Care, which offers smaller particle sizes for better absorption into grass roots and science-backed formulas designed with environmental factors in mind. Additionally, many bio-based formulas offer pet-friendly ingredients, so you don’t have to worry about your furry friends playing on the lawn after application.

Different brands may also use different combinations of nutrients that make them more suitable for certain types of turf or soils than others. This makes it important to consider all the different factors when selecting a fertilizer product from any brand name company like Scotts or Vigoro.

While cost will always be an important factor when deciding upon a fertilizer, homeowners should take other research into account before buying anything. This includes customer reviews and assessments from knowledgeable sources within their local community.

Reviews and Suggestions

Reviews and Suggestions
Considering what you need for your lawn, take a look at reviews and suggestions from other homeowners who have used both Scotts and Vigoro. While cost analysis shows that Vigoro is 31.5% cheaper than Scotts, the latter offers better customer support options as well as more lush and natural-looking grass growth due to its Turf Builder Weed and Feed products with ASSURANCE Particle Technology offering weed control down to the roots along with extended feeding up to two months.

However, it’s been noted that certain environmental factors should be taken into consideration when choosing between these brands such as shade, sunlight, foot traffic, or pet use which could affect the performance of either fertilizer product – not forgetting soil type too.

In addition, customers may also want to factor in a money-back guarantee on their purchase. While Scott provides this option, none has been found for Vigoro’s brand products so far, although Home Depot customers did give them a positive rating of 50%.

Ultimately, finding the right product comes down to personal preference, but understanding how each performs will help save time and money in selecting only what works best for one’s individual needs

Where to Buy: Scotts Turf Builder Weed and Feed

Where to Buy: Scotts Turf Builder Weed and Feed
If you’re in the market for a weed and feed fertilizer, Scotts Turf Builder Weed and Feed is an excellent choice. It has been engineered to provide organic solutions that will enhance your lawn’s health while minimizing its environmental impact.

The time-released nutrients guarantee long-lasting effects over multiple growing seasons.

Additionally, Scotts offers money-back guarantees on all of their products. So, if you’re not satisfied with the results, they’ll refund your purchase price – no questions asked! For optimal performance when applying this product, it’s important to consider how much sun or shade your lawn receives throughout the day, as well as any other environmental factors such as foot traffic and pet use that may affect its growth rate.

You should also be aware of what types of fertilizer claims best suit your specific lawn needs during different times within each growing season. This will ensure success with Scotts Turf Builder Weed & Feed or similar Scott’s brand products over time.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Fertilizer

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Fertilizer
Choosing the right fertilizer for your lawn requires careful consideration of factors like shade, sunlight, foot traffic, and pet use.

For weed prevention, it is important to take into account local environmental conditions when selecting a product. Pet owners should consider products with reduced toxicity to protect their furry friends from accidental ingestion or contact with potential irritants.

Many companies offer money-back guarantees if you are not satisfied with their product, so be sure to check out customer-quality service departments before committing to a purchase. Additionally, certain types of grass growth may benefit more from certain kinds of fertilizers than others.

Checking at your local garden shop can help determine which types will work best for you and save time by avoiding trial and error on different brands or products that don’t ultimately fit your needs.

If cost is an issue, looking at pricing online can lead you towards savings opportunities as well as finding customer reviews about how various types of products work in practice rather than just theory alone.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How long will the effects of Scotts and Vigoro fertilizer last?

Experience lush, green lawns for months with Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers! Their effects will last up to two months when applied correctly.

Is it safe to use Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers on my grass?

Both Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers are generally safe to use on grass. However, it is important to carefully read the instructions as some ingredients may not be suitable for all lawns.

Are there any side effects associated with using Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers?

Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers are generally safe to use, but it is important to carefully follow the instructions for application.

Are there any natural alternatives to Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers?

For a natural lawn care solution, consider Sunday Lawn Care. It uses organic compost and plant food, without any harmful chemicals. It’s easy to apply and promotes lush green grass growth while being environmentally friendly.

Are there any special instructions for applying Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers?

For a lush lawn, it’s important to apply Scotts and Vigoro fertilizers carefully. Follow the instructions on the packaging for the best results, taking into account factors such as shade, sunlight, foot traffic, and pet use.


Your lawn is an important part of your home. With the right fertilizer, you can achieve a lush, green lawn that’s the envy of your neighborhood. When it comes to choosing between Vigoro and Scotts, both have their strengths and weaknesses.

Scotts has better customer service and produces a more natural-looking lawn, but Vigoro is cheaper and better for weed prevention.

Ultimately, the choice between the two brands is personal and should be based on your specific needs and budget. For example, if you have a lot of shade and pet use, you may want to opt for Vigoro Weed and Feed for its extended feeding and weed prevention.

On the other hand, if you need a fertilizer to promote lush, green grass, Scotts Turf Builder Weed and Feed may be a better choice.

No matter which you choose, you can be sure that your lawn will look its best

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is a published author and software engineer and agriculture expert from the US. To date, he has helped thousands of people make their yards lush and thick.